Generic(Collection) Usage in the .NET Framework

Generics provide a way for developers to define subroutines, functions, fields, properties as well as classes, structures, interfaces and even delegates in such a way that the parameters are not of any particular type.  In a sense the constructs are defined in a generic approach.

The .NET Framework contains the following namespaces:System.Collections, System.Collections.Generic.    The latter mimics very much the features of the former. 

System.Collections namespace (nongeneric)

ICollection (size, enumeration, thread safety) derives from IEnumerable
IComparer Allows two objects to be compared  
IDictionary Collection object to represent its contents using name/value pairs derives from ICollection, IEnumerable
IDictionaryEnumerator Enumerates the contents of a type supporting IDictionary derives from IEnumerator
IEnumerable Returns IEnumerator interface for a collection  
IEnumerator Enables for each style iteration of items in collection  
IList Provides add, remove and index items in a list of objects derives from ICollection, IEnumerable

ICollection is the most primitive interface of the System.Collections

Public Interface ICollection
  Inherits IEnumerable
  Sub CopyTo(ByVal array As Array, ByVal index As Integer)
  ReadOnly Property Count() As Integer
  ReadOnly Property IsSynchronized() As Boolean
  ReadOnly Property SyncRoot() As Object
End Interface


IDictionary is a simple collection that maintains a set of name/value pairs.  Using this type allows you such features as returning an item by say license plate number or persons name for example.

Public Interface IDictionary
  Inherits ICollection, IEnumerable
  Sub Add(ByVal key As Object, ByVal value As Object)
  Sub Clear()
  Function Contains(ByVal key As Object) As Boolean
  Function GetEnumerator() As IDictionaryEnumerator
  Sub Remove(ByVal key As Object)
  ReadOnly Property IsFixedSize() As Boolean
  ReadOnly Property IsReadOnly() As Boolean
  Property Item(ByVal key As Object) As Object
  ReadOnly Property Keys() As ICollection
  ReadOnly Property Values() As ICollection
End Interface

IList provides the ability to insert, remove and index items

Public Interface IList
  Inherits ICollection, IEnumerable
  Function Add(ByVal value As Object) As Integer
  Sub Clear()
  Function Contains(ByVal value As Object) As Boolean
  Function IndexOf(ByVal value As Object) As Integer
  Sub Insert(ByVal index As Integer, ByVal value As Object)
  Sub Remove(ByVal value As Object)
  Sub RemoveAt(ByVal index As Integer)
  ReadOnly Property IsFixedSize() As Boolean
  ReadOnly Property IsReadOnly() As Boolean
  Property Item(ByVal index As Integer) As Object
End Interface


So far I have show the key interfaces within System.Collections.  The interfaces alone do not provide the implementation.  The following will document the relationships between the above interfaces and the specific types within the System.Collections namespace.


ArrayList dynamically sized
Dim personList as New ArrayList()
personList.AddRange(New Person(){New Person(“dave”), New Person(“tom”)}
Hashtable collection whereby each item is represented by a numerical key IDictionary
Queue first in – first out queue with members Dequeue() (removes object at the top of queue), Enqueue() (adds object to end of queue), Peek() (returns object at the beginning of queue without removing it) ICollection
SortedList similar to dictionary however items can be accessed by ordinal position IDictionary
Stack last in – first out queue using push, pop and peek ICollection

While the above are types of System.Collections there are additional types within the System.Collections.Specialized such as BitVector32 (collection of booleans), CollectionsUtil (ignores case in strings), HybridDictionary (starts as ListDictionary however it switches automatically to hashTable as the collection gets large), ListDictionary (for small collections of 10 items or less), NameValueCollection (sorted collection of string keys and string values), StringCollection (collection of strings), StringDictionary (a hashtable with key values strongly typed to string type), StringEnumerator.


Now with respect to the System.Collections.Generic namespace; it contains a series of types that leverage the features of the for mentioned collections however they bring to the forefront the advantages: improved performance by avoiding boxing and unboxing, type-safety, code maintenance issues.  The generic collection when declared specifies the type of the collection item.  In the following example we create a generic collection that can only contain integers.  If the developer attempts to insert anything other than an Integer they will get a design time error.

Boxing/Unboxing is a term that is used when a value type variable is stored in a reference type structure.  This occurs with all nongeneric types as they operate of the System.Objects type.

For example:
Dim ar as New ArrayList()
ar.Add(123) ‘boxing occurs
Dim i as Integer = CType(ar(0), Integer) ‘unboxing occurs


Using a generic collection:
Dim ar as New List(Of Integer)
ar.Add(10) ‘no boxing
Dim i as Integer = ar(0) ‘no unboxing

The following is a list of interfaces within the System.Collections.Generic namespace: ICollections(Of T), IComparer(Of T), IDictionary(Of K, V), IEnumerable(Of T), IEnumerator(Of T), and IList(Of T).  There respective classes are as follows:

Collection(Of T) generic collection  
Comparer(Of T) compares two generic objects  
Dictionary(Of K, V) name/value pairs  
List(Of T) dynamically resizable  
Queue(Of T) FIFO collection  
SortedDictionary(Of K, V) sorted set of name/value pairs  
Stack(Of T) LIFO collection  
LinkedList(Of T) doubly linked list  
ReadOnlyCollection(Of T) readonly set of items  


The convention is that generic types specify their placeholders typically with T to represent the type of variable the collection is to contain.

<p$1$2$3$4$5$6>  <p$1$2$3$4$5$6>  <p$1$2$3$4$5$6> 

So far we have discussed generic in the sense of a collection class.  With all the same benefits a method can be defined as generic.  The following example shows how the method was defined to take two parameters of Type T.  Using a generic function like this can allow one function to operate on more than one type of variable.  The convention is to follow the method name with the type of the parameters passed in.  Calling the following function would look something like Test(Of String)(“test1”, “Test2”)

Public Function Test(Of T)(ByRef o1 as T, ByRef o2 as T) as T
  ‘do something
End Function


It is possible to establish constraints with respect to the type of T.  The following is a complete list of the types of constraints:
Of T as Structure > the type parameter must be a value type (ie. structure)
Of T as Class > the type parameter must be a reference type (i.e. classes)
Of T as New > the type parameter must have a default constructor
Of T as NameOf BaseClass > the type parameter must be derived from the class specified by NameOfBaseClass
Of T as NameOfInterface > the type parameter must implement the interface specified by NameOfInterface

’new items must have a default constructor
Public Class TestClass(Of T as New)
  ‘stuff here
End Class


The term generic can apply to Interfaces as well. In any case the interface will define the contract that the implementing class must adhere to.  When implementing a generic interface the supporting type specifies the placeholder type:

Public Interface IMyInterface(Of T)
  Function Add(ByVal x as T, ByVal y as T) as T
End Interface

Public Class MyClass
  Implements IMyInterface(Of Integer)

Public Function Add(ByVal x as Integer, ByVal y as Integer) as Integer
  Return x + y
End Function

By all means utilize the generic collection namespace over the system.collection nongeneric namespace.  In addition to improved performance(avoiding boxing/unboxing) your code will avoid type-safety issues of earlier releases of .NET.



comments powered by Disqus


Recent Tweets

"Setting up and Getting Started with Power BI Embedded | Data Exposed"… #webcast #feedly
Retweeted by @dyardy @scottgu @victoriabeckham Worlds collide, double take on that photo!
@scottgu @victoriabeckham Worlds collide, double take on that photo!
@projectedxyz It is really easy, what are you doing (isn't this data which on the web)